Decision fatigue: what it is, why it matters, and how to manage it at work

Decision fatigue is an insidious phenomenon that affects many employees — often without them realizing it. Faced with a constant stream of choices and responsibilities, the brain gradually becomes overwhelmed. This leads to poor decision-making and increased stress.

But how can you recognize this mental strain — and what can you do to protect your employees’ mental health? In this article, we’ll break down the mechanisms behind decision fatigue, its consequences, and the concrete actions that can help reduce its impact.

‍

What is decision fatigue?

The term speaks for itself: decision fatigue is a state of mental exhaustion caused by a buildup of decisions. The more choices we’re forced to make — especially under pressure — the harder it becomes to make the right ones.

When high-stakes decisions pile up and the workload keeps growing, the brain reaches a saturation point. Cognitive functions slow down, mental clarity fades, and emotional regulation becomes harder. At that point, even the most trivial decision can feel overwhelming.

This typically happens later in the day, when cognitive and emotional resources have already been heavily taxed. But if recovery time is too short, and pressure builds up daily, temporary mental fatigue can evolve into lasting burnout — with serious consequences for mental and physical health, relationships, and overall wellbeing.

What causes decision fatigue at work?

Decision fatigue stems from a combination of workplace factors that overstrain our cognitive capacity.

The first — and most common — is excessive workload. Employees are forced to make back-to-back decisions, often under tight deadlines. As a result, they lose the space needed for reflection and thoughtful choices.

According to a 2023 Workplace Intelligence study, mental overload is one of the leading sources of work-related stress for 72% of employees.

Stressful environments, where time pressure and high expectations are the norm, make things worse. On top of that, the lack of proper breaks robs the brain of the recovery time it needs to reset and stay efficient.

Another major contributor is hyperconnectivity. Constant exposure to emails, messages, alerts, and information flows creates cognitive noise. Faced with this stream of input and frequent demands, employees can feel overwhelmed — making it harder to prioritize and decide.

Together, these factors create fertile ground for decision fatigue: a state where mental clarity diminishes, the risk of errors increases, and decision quality declines over the course of the day.

‍

How decision fatigue affects employees’ mental health

Decision fatigue is not like physical tiredness. It’s not caused by lack of sleep or physical effort, but by mental overload — from having to make too many decisions in too little time.

Some roles are more exposed than others. Managers, medical professionals, and executives, for example, are particularly at risk.

And the effects are far from trivial. Left unchecked, decision fatigue can have serious repercussions on mental health and professional performance.

Anxiety, stress, and the risk of burnout

Too many decisions can quickly trigger high levels of stress, making each choice more difficult and exhausting. While manageable in the short term, chronic stress soon sets in.

Uncertainty grows. Confidence drops. Decisions are rushed — or avoided — to save time. Stress no longer drives performance: it becomes a barrier to wellbeing.

Over time, this stress can turn into chronic anxiety. Employees exposed to excessive decision pressure are at greater risk of mental exhaustion and burnout.

Impact on motivation and engagement

Decision fatigue undermines motivation and satisfaction. It weakens the ability to stay focused, make sound judgments, or stay confident. This can directly affect quality of life at work, reduce mental wellbeing, and increase the risk of absenteeism.

‍

A closer look: HR professionals and decision fatigue

While HR professionals are key to supporting employee wellbeing, their own mental health is often under strain. Constantly navigating between logic and empathy, they face difficult decisions every day — from resolving conflicts to implementing strategic policies, all while absorbing growing organizational pressure.

According to teale’s 2024 HR Mental Health Barometer:

• 40% of HR professionals say they are dissatisfied with their work-life balance
• Only 37% say they wake up feeling rested and ready to start the day

These numbers highlight a high psychological load, especially given that HR decisions directly affect people and company culture. The emotional toll is real — and growing.

How to prevent and manage decision fatigue at work

We make up to 35,000 decisions a day — from small daily choices to major professional calls. No wonder our brains get overwhelmed.

But decision fatigue isn’t inevitable. With the right strategies, it can be anticipated, prevented, and reduced.

Recognizing the signs of decision fatigue

Avant de pouvoir agir, il est essentiel de reconnaître les signaux qui témoignent d’un épuisement lié à une charge décisionnelle et cognitive excessive :

The first step is awareness. Here are key signs to look out for:

• Procrastination or indecision: when employees delay or avoid choices due to overwhelm
• Frequent mistakes: a sign of mental and cognitive fatigue
• Difficulty focusing: mental fog caused by too many decisions
• Rising stress levels, potentially leading to anxiety
• Frustration and dissatisfaction: especially when employees feel unable to make effective decisions or regret the consequences of past choices

Self-reflection is useful: if every decision, even minor ones, causes stress or hesitation, decision fatigue may be at play.

Leaders should also watch for signs in their teams: increasing reluctance to decide, stress reactions, disengagement, or loss of confidence in one’s own judgment.

Managing time and priorities effectively

Work organization is key to limiting decision overload. Structured routines and clear habits reduce the number of unnecessary choices during the day.

Tips include:

• Setting clear daily and weekly priorities
• Breaking tasks into small, time-limited steps
• Using detailed schedules or planning tools
• Delegating responsibilities when possible — especially for managers balancing multiple roles

Time and priority management training can also empower employees to stay focused and make decisions more calmly.

‍

Creating a workplace that supports recovery

Taking breaks is not a luxury — it’s essential to protect mental clarity.

Pausing throughout the day allows the brain to “breathe” and restore its cognitive capacity. But it’s not just up to the employee. Organizations play a key role in shaping a culture that values mental recovery.

Concrete steps include:

• Creating dedicated relaxation spaces
• Encouraging screen-free breaks
• Scheduling collective downtime into the calendar

Breaking free from the “always-on” mindset enables employees to gain perspective and make better decisions — without guilt or pressure.

Taking action: how teale supports decision fatigue prevention

To help organizations turn these insights into action, teale offers practical solutions for managing decision fatigue and supporting employee mental health.

Our digital mental health platform includes a dedicated program on “Decision-making”, helping employees:

• Reduce stress
• Build confidence
• Manage fear of regret
• Understand decision-making traps
• Navigate emotional or mental overload

In addition, personalized support is available through therapy or coaching. Whether it’s working with a psychologist or a personal development expert, employees can explore tailored strategies to better handle information overload and restore mental balance.